Hi Maverick and Vipinb,
Thank you both for your comments.
@Maverick - yes, that is definitely one of the realities of the current age. Ideas are much more visible now, and many concepts can be understood very quickly once someone sees the problem being solved.
At the same time, I think there is an important difference between being inspired by a general need in the market and simply copying another developer’s work, product execution, UI, documentation, branding, implementation details or commercial positioning.
For me, the value of a professional NinjaTrader AddOn is not only the initial idea. It is the implementation, reliability, workflow design, error handling, user experience, testing, support, updates and long-term maintenance.
That is the part I have focused on with AT Market Replay Data Pro, providing a polished and supported workflow for users who regularly work with NinjaTrader Market Replay data and prefer to save time using a ready-to-use solution instead of having to build and maintain their own tool from scratch.
@Vipinb - regarding The Intentional Trader’s AddOn, I don’t want to make an unfair comparison because I have not tested their current version in detail. From what I understand, their tool is also focused on making Market Replay downloads easier, so there may be some overlap in the general idea.
The focus of AT Market Replay Data Pro is to make the official NinjaTrader Market Replay download workflow more structured, visual and easier to control: selecting a date range, selecting one or more instruments/contracts, generating the download queue, monitoring the process and reducing repetitive manual work.
Regarding the futures contract rollover point, I’m not completely sure what you mean by having to manually copy tick data files to get continuity on the chart. In my normal use, I don’t need to touch tick data files for charts to work correctly across futures contracts.
Since futures contracts expire and each contract has its own symbol, continuity usually depends on how the instrument, contract month, chart settings and replay data are being used. It may be a configuration or workflow issue rather than something that requires manually editing or copying tick files.
I would be careful with manually moving or copying tick/replay files, because doing that incorrectly could create confusing or inaccurate test conditions. If you explain the exact workflow you are using, I can better understand the problem you are trying to solve.